Management consultants for upstream
oil and gas producers and service companies
Our focus is to work with management teams to develop and
implement business strategies that are practical, sustainable and allow
organizations to achieve their full potential. Our consultants have
long histories of working closely with senior executive teams of
firms of all sizes to help their companies not only be successful,
but achieve performance that stands out relative to
peers.
.
Contact us at insight@energy-cg.com to
find out how we can help you. Alternatively, we can set up a complimentary
ZOOM
consultation
to demonstrate our capabilities, and if engaged, to interact
directly with your project teams, whereever they might be.
US Natural Gas
Supply Summary
In this section we provide a brief overview of the US natural gas supply
situation. In the first row of charts, we maintain supply charts to provide
view on overall volumes and trends. For updated charts please
contact us at insight@energy-cg.com. We also
do detailed supply analysis on specific areas, an example of which is
provided in the second row of charts. In these charts we summarize the results of the USGS
resource assessments for nonconventional resources in the Delaware Basin and
Midland Basin regions of the west Texas and southeastern New Mexico, which
are collectively known as the Permian Basin. The USGS estimates that the
nonconventional resources in the western part of the Permian Basin
(the Delaware Basin) have about 270 TCF of gas, which, when
combined with the estimates for gas for the eastern Permian Basin (the Midland Basin), gives a total of 285 TCF. For perspective,
if we were to consider the Permian a standalone country, its nonconventional
gas resources would rank 6th in the world. It's a big number, and has the
potential to dramatically swing the focus of the natural gas supply story in
the USA away from Appalachia and onto West Texas.
Reported Production for Main US Non-Conventional Regions For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
US Natural Gas Production with Marcellus, Utica,
and Eagle Ford Breakout
The Three Primary Regions of the Permian Basin For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Where Would the Permian Basin Rank Globally in
Natural Gas Resources if It Were Considered a Separate Country? For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
USA Natural Gas Demand, Production (Supply), Imports, Exports, and Price
As reported by the EIA For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
The chart to the left provides a single page reference for USA natural
gas market fundamentals. The obvious trends since the
advent of large scale shale gas drilling in the middle
of the previous decade are: 1)
Lower natural gas prices 2) Increasing demand in response
to the lower prices 3) Falling imports and growing exports.
Longer term, development of the
deep Utica, super shale is starting to rev up. We currently estimate
the resource potential of this
play to be in excess of 400 TCF, a significant portion of
which may be economic at less than $2/mmbtu. As a reminder, three early wells in the deep,
dry Utica in sw PA tested at 59 MMCFD, 73 MMCFD, and 63
MMCFD. All three had flowing pressures of 8000 psi or higher.
See the following links for more details:
Scotts Run (73 MMCFD) well;
Gaut4IH (63 MMCFD) well; and
Claysville
Sportsman's Club No. 1(59 MMCFD) well.
US Natural Gas
Demand Summary In this
section we provide a brief overview of US natural gas demand situation. If
looking for updates on any of the provided charts or our current assessment of
natural gas demand, both for the USA and internationally, please contact us.
ECG Assessment of Horizontal Drilling Activity
in Several Large Shale Gas Plays in the USA (February 2020) For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Map of USA Onshore Gas Drilling Activity
February 2019 For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Natural Gas and the US Power Sector Another short to medium term factor in North American natural gas demand is fuel-on-fuel competition in the electric power industry.
So, while there is a secular, long term shift out of coal in the power sector
(noted below, in the exhibit titled, "US Electric Power Generation ByType: Coal
Market Share is Declining"), the power sector has also become adept at
short term, back and forth switching between between coal and natural gas fueled
power plants. The reason is to arbitrage relative price differences
between the fuels. Our research
(see below) illustrates that once natural gas prices at Henry Hub move below
$3.00/mmbtu, gas becomes increasingly competitive with coal for power
burn, and vice versa.
Fuel-on-fuel competition
between coal and natural gas for power generation fuel burn For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
As this chart illustrates, once natural gas
prices move below $3.00/mmbtu at Henry Hub, the cash cost of large scale power
generation, mainly consisting of fuel and variable opex, starts to work in favor of natural
gas. As a result when prices fall to such levels, we see operators increasing the use of natural gas fired power plants to
take advantage of the lower costs. Obviously, the more natural gas
prices fall below the $3.00 threshold, the greater the incentive to switch
over to natural gas. This has effectively placed a floor under
natural gas prices at around $2.65/mmbtu.
The left hand graph in
the next row of exhibits, clearly shows the relationship described in
the previous paragraph, i.e. as natural gas prices move up and down
relative to coal prices, fuel volumes shift as well. We
intentionally used the same x_axis scale for the two charts, which
allows us to directly compare the relationship between natural gas and
coal prices and changes in the relative amount of power generated by the
two types.
Year-On-Year Change in USA
Terawatt-Hours (Updated February 2020) For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
USA Coal and Natural Gas Fired Terawatt-Hours vs
Power Generation for the Renewable Mix of Solar, Wind, and Hydro (Updated February 2020) For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
US Electric Power Generation ByType: Coal
Market Share is Declining (Updated February 2020) For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
US Utility-Scale Electric Generating Capacity Retirements (2008-2020) For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Map Showing Location of US Power Generation Facilities
by Type For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Comparison of the Cost of Power Generation for
Different Technologies and Across Time On a New Build, Levelized
Overnight Cost Basis Using EIA Data and Cost Estimation Methodology For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Cost of Power Comparison By Technology for New Build Power Installations Levelized CAPEX, OPEX ex
Fuel, Sept, 2015, Est. Nat Gas Fuel Cost, Fall 2015 For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Return to Web Page Index Regional Price Variation Across the US Natural
Gas Market The spot price, trading hub maps presented below
illustrate the price impact that plays can have on the underlying commidty
price. In this case, the
Marcellus and Utica in the northeast USA are hi-lighted. As shown by the spot price map
of the northeast USA, prompt prices in the Marcellus/Utica area were about half
or less that of Henry Hub/NYMEX pricing in January and February 2015.
Select USA Natural Gas Hubs
(These map locations should roughly correspond with the hubs listed to
the right) or Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Reported January 2015
Natural Gas Spot Prices at Selected Trading Hubs in the
United States: This demonstrates pricing relative to
Henry Hub For
Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Reported January 2015
Natural Gas Spot Prices At Selected Trading Hubs in the Northeast United
States For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Reported Natural Gas
Spot Prices At Selected Trading Hubs Across the United States as of
March 2016 For Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Reported Natural Gas
Spot Prices At Selected Trading Hubs in the Northeast United States as
of March 2016 For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Shale Gas Technology and Productivity Trends The rapid pace and magnitude with which
shale play technology is improving is illustrated by the two plots below. The
one on the left is an example is from an early shale gas well with an initial
rate of about 3 MMCFD, and an EUR of about 4.5 BCF. As the horizontal drilling,
multistage fracking technology improved and became less expensive, individual
well rates and recoveries climbed. After years of this dynamic, the industry is
now developing super wells, which are capable of flowing as much as 60-80 MMCFD,
and producing as much as 30 BCF from a single well. This 20-25x increase in
rate, and 4-6 times increase in EUR, is accomplished with about a 2x-2.5x increase in
well cost. Such "super" wells are becoming increasingly common. See
map below for reported initial rates from Marcellus wells completed in NE PA in
2019.
Rig Productivity
Growth Within One Major Shale Gas Play For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
How is this possible you might ask? Well, this is one of our
speciality areas, i.e. tracking new technology in the upstream oil and
gas industry, and assessing how that technology "moves the needle" for
companies and the larger industry. Below is an example from an
operator showing how over a few short years, it managed to increase average
drilling penetration rates in a major shale play by a factor of almost
three, from 2000'/day to almost 6000'/day. For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Northeast Marcellus Initial Rates Reported for One Operator mid-2019 For Higher Resolution View, Click Image
As a result of this technological revolution, the North American natural gas
supply curve (below), as we calculate it, has been dramatically pushed down, and
flattened. The implications are that large volumes of gas can be developed
at lower breakeven costs. Meaning the shale revolution is not likely to be a
flash in the pan, but rather a force of positive change that has the
potential to lower the cost of living
for everyone. There is no better example of this than what is
happening in the deep, dry Utica in
southwest Pennsylvania.
A North American Natural
Gas Cost of Supply Curve October 2015 For Larger, Higher Resolution View, Click Image
Top 40 Natural Gas Companies in the USA by Daily
Output (NGSA)